2021 - Devyn DiPasquale - P.V.H.S. Softball - Coach David Fletcher

2021 - Nicolas Iacovo - P.V.H.S. Football & Track - Coaches Ken Burke & Joel hornton

----

2020 - Due to the pandemic, no sports awards were given this year

----

2019 - Daniell Gaita - Totowa - P.V.H.S. - Softball (Coacj Kathy Hill)

2019 - Steven Nitch - Little Falls - P.V.H.S. - Baseball (Coach John Mazzo)

----

2018 - Alyssa Bernardo - Softball / Coach Hill

2018 - Thomas Marretta - Wrestling & Football / Coach Benvenuti

----

2017 - Jennifer Sabbak - Field Hockey & Girls Lacrosse 

2017 - Christopher Watkins - Baseball 

----

2016 - Gianni Palumbo - Wrestling / Football

2016 - Daniella Sole - Basketball

----

2015 - Alexandria Goldinak - Basketball

2015 - Lucas Prospero - Ice Hockey

----

2014 - Gabriella Campen - Gymnastics

2014 - Thomas Dunphy - Wrestling

----

2013 - Louis Anthony Caltagironi - Track / Football

2013 - Lara LoBue - Gymnastics

----

2012 - Nicholas Pezzano

2012 - Jasmine Sconliafurno

----

2011 - Alexis Arena

2011 - Danielle Coiro

2011 - Jack Pohlman

----

2010 - Matthew Coiro

----

2009 - Andrew Greco

2009 - Brittany Maigione

----

2008 - Samantha DeCeglie

2008 - Joseph Wassal

----

2007 - Justin Ottino

2007 - Annamarie Russo